Skip to content
Workouts

Cable Fly Alternative: 8 Swaps for Dumbbells, Bands and Bodyweight

Nadia Popescu

By Nadia Popescu, Strength & Conditioning Writer · Updated 22 November 2026

The best cable fly alternative for most people is a resistance band fly, because a band pulls from the side like a cable does and keeps your chest working right to the point where your hands meet. If you only have dumbbells, use a dumbbell fly (flat, incline or low-to-high) and pair it with a squeeze press. In a commercial gym with no free pulley, the pec deck is the closest machine match. Below are eight swaps grouped by the kit you have, with how to do each one and an honest note on what it keeps and loses compared with the cable.

What the cable fly does that you are trying to replace

Before picking a swap, it helps to know what makes the cable fly worth doing in the first place. Three things:

  • Constant tension. A cable pulls along the line of the rope, not straight down. That means it keeps resisting your arms through the whole arc, including the top of the rep where a dumbbell goes slack.
  • Adduction across the body. Your chest's main job in a fly is horizontal adduction: pulling your upper arm in towards the midline. With a cable you can carry your hands past each other, so the pecs work into a fully shortened position.
  • A loaded stretch. At the start of each rep your arms are open and the chest is lengthened under load. The cable keeps that stretch loaded without dumping all the weight onto your shoulders.

You also get pulley height (high-to-low, mid or low-to-high) and small, measurable jumps on the stack. No single alternative copies all of that. Each one below keeps some and loses some, so the trick is choosing the one that keeps what matters to you.

How we put this together

This guide draws on established exercise technique, published research on chest training, and how each movement loads the chest through its range. We have not run a study of our own, and we link the papers we rely on so you can read them yourself.

Quick comparison

AlternativeKitKeeps vs the cableLoses vs the cable
Band flyTube bands, door anchor or rackSideways pull, tension at the squeezeFine loading, tension in the stretch
Dumbbell fly (flat, incline, low-to-high)Dumbbells, benchLoaded stretch, easy progressionTension at the top
Dumbbell squeeze pressDumbbells, benchInward squeeze, heavy loadingThe wide fly arc
Pec deckGym machineConstant tension, stable pathAngle choice, crossing the midline
Ring or TRX flyRings or suspension trainerLoaded stretch, core demandEasy load control
Svend press or plate squeezeOne or two platesAdduction effort at the midlineStretch, range of motion
Single-arm landmine pressBarbell, landmineArm travelling across the bodyIsolation, wide arc
Deficit push-upTwo blocks, books or handlesDeep stretch, no kitIsolation, constant tension

Band alternatives

1. Resistance band fly

This is the closest home swap. Anchor a tube band at chest height, either a door anchor or the upright of a rack, and face away from it holding a handle in each hand (or use two bands, one either side of a doorway, for a true crossover feel).

  1. Step forward until there is tension in the band with your arms open wide and a soft bend in your elbows.
  2. Sweep your hands forward and together in a hugging arc, letting them cross slightly at the end.
  3. Squeeze for a second, then open back out slowly until you feel a stretch across your chest.

Keeps: the sideways line of pull and tension at the top, which is the cable fly's biggest advantage over dumbbells. Moving the anchor high or low gives you high-to-low and low-to-high versions too. Loses: bands get harder as they stretch, so the open, stretched position is the lightest part of the rep. Loading also moves in bigger jumps than a cable stack.

Bands are not a lesser tool. A meta-analysis comparing elastic resistance with machines and dumbbells found no meaningful difference in strength gains for the upper or lower body (Lopes et al., 2019). Our guide to the best resistance bands in the UK covers tube sets with handles and door anchors.

Dumbbell alternatives

2. Dumbbell fly (flat, incline and low-to-high)

The dumbbell fly is the classic substitute and the one most people can do tonight.

  1. Lie on a flat bench with a dumbbell in each hand, arms above your chest, palms facing each other and elbows slightly bent.
  2. Lower the weights out to the sides in a wide arc until your upper arms are about level with your torso and you feel a stretch.
  3. Bring them back up along the same arc, stopping a few centimetres before the dumbbells touch.

For the upper chest, set the bench to about 30 degrees for an incline fly; this is the dumbbell version of a low-to-high cable fly. For a standing low-to-high option, hold light dumbbells at your sides and sweep them up and in to chin height, though the load here falls mainly on the front of your shoulders, so treat it as a light finisher.

Keeps: a heavily loaded stretch and simple progression with adjustable dumbbells. Loses: tension at the top. Once your arms are vertical, gravity pulls through your joints and the pecs switch off. Flyes also load the chest less than pressing overall: one EMG study of trained men found the barbell bench press produced higher pec activity than dumbbell flyes across most of the rep (Solstad et al., 2020). Treat any fly as an add-on to a press, not a replacement.

3. Dumbbell squeeze press

This covers the part of the fly that dumbbell flyes miss.

  1. Lie on a flat bench and press two dumbbells together over your chest, palms facing each other.
  2. Squeeze them hard into each other and keep squeezing as you lower them to your chest.
  3. Press back up without letting them drift apart.

Keeps: active inward squeeze through the whole rep, and you can go heavier than with flyes. Loses: the wide arc and the stretch. Pair it with dumbbell flyes and you cover both ends of the range.

Machine alternative

4. Pec deck

If your gym's cable stations are always busy, the pec deck (also called the chest fly machine) is the nearest like-for-like swap.

  1. Set the seat so the handles or pads sit at mid-chest height.
  2. Start with your arms open and a slight stretch, then bring the handles together in front of you.
  3. Pause, then let them back slowly without the stack touching down.

Keeps: steady tension through most of the range, plus a fixed path that lets you push hard without balancing anything. Loses: you cannot change the angle much and your hands cannot cross the midline. If you do not have access to one either, see our pec deck alternatives.

Bodyweight and suspension alternatives

5. Ring or TRX fly

  1. Set rings or suspension straps around hip height. Hold a handle in each hand and lean forward into a push-up position with arms straight in front of you.
  2. Let your arms open out to the sides as your chest lowers, keeping a slight bend in the elbows and your body in a straight line.
  3. Pull your arms back together to return to the start.

Adjust difficulty by walking your feet forward or back. Start much more upright than you think you need, because this exercise gets hard quickly.

Keeps: a heavily loaded stretch and serious core work. Loses: precise loading, and like dumbbells it goes light at the top. It is also harder on the shoulders if you lower too far. Our gymnastic rings guide covers sets that suit home use.

6. Deficit push-up

Place your hands on two blocks, push-up handles or stacks of books so your chest can drop below hand level.

  1. Set up in a push-up position with a straight body line.
  2. Lower until your chest sits between your hands and you feel a clear stretch.
  3. Press back up.

Keeps: a deep, loaded stretch with almost no kit. Loses: isolation, because your triceps and shoulders share the work, and the tension fades near lockout. It is a press, not a fly, but if the stretch was why you liked cable flyes, this delivers it. Our push-up guide has easier and harder versions.

Plate and barbell alternatives

7. Svend press or plate squeeze

The Svend press is a light, odd-looking move that trains the squeeze.

  1. Stand tall and press two small plates (or one larger plate) together between your palms at chest height.
  2. Squeeze them as hard as you can and push them straight out in front of you.
  3. Bring them back to your chest without easing off the squeeze.

Keeps: hard adduction effort near the midline, the bit dumbbell flyes cannot reach. Loses: the stretch and most of the range. The plate weight barely matters; the squeeze is the exercise. Use it as a finisher.

8. Single-arm landmine press

  1. Wedge one end of a barbell into a corner or landmine attachment and stand facing the loaded end in a split stance.
  2. Hold the sleeve at your shoulder with one hand.
  3. Press up and forward, letting your hand finish in line with the middle of your body.

Keeps: an arm path that travels forward and across the body, which brings in the upper chest more than a straight overhead press. See our full landmine press guide for setup. Loses: isolation and the wide fly arc. It is a pressing movement with a fly-like finish, best for people who want something shoulder-friendly that can be loaded heavily.

Which one should you pick?

  • You train at home with bands: band fly, with the anchor at chest height, then high or low to change angle.
  • You only own dumbbells: incline or flat dumbbell fly, followed by a squeeze press.
  • You are in a gym and the cables are busy: pec deck.
  • You want the deepest stretch: dumbbell fly or deficit push-up.
  • You want the squeeze at the top: band fly, squeeze press or Svend press.
  • You travel or have no kit: deficit push-up, or a ring fly if you pack a suspension trainer.
  • You want to target the upper chest: incline dumbbell fly, low-to-high band fly or single-arm landmine press.

Do not lose sleep over picking the perfect tool. A meta-analysis comparing free weights with machines found no meaningful difference in muscle growth when the two were compared directly (Haugen et al., 2023). Effort and consistency matter far more.

Common mistakes

Going too heavy on flyes. Heavy dumbbell or ring flyes turn into a press as your elbows bend more and more. Pick a weight that lets you keep the same slight elbow bend throughout.

Overstretching. Dropping your arms far below your torso places big loads on the front of the shoulder. Stop when your upper arms reach about torso level.

Letting bands snap back. The return is half the rep. Open your arms over two to three seconds rather than letting the band pull you back.

Using a fly as your only chest exercise. Flyes and their alternatives work best after a press such as the dumbbell bench press, as a second exercise for 2 to 3 sets of 10 to 15 reps.

Should you buy a cable machine?

If you keep coming back to cable work, it might be worth it, but only if you will use it for more than flyes. A cable crossover machine gives you rows, pulldowns, face pulls and leg work too, though it needs floor and ceiling space. A single wall-mounted pulley does a cable fly one arm at a time for a fraction of the size. Compare options in our best cable machine UK guide.

Recommended reads

  1. Cable fly: how to do it and variations
  2. Cable crossover alternatives for home gyms
  3. Pec deck alternatives
  4. The best resistance bands in the UK
  5. The best cable machine in the UK

Frequently asked questions

What is the best cable fly alternative?

For most people it is a resistance band fly, because the band pulls from the side like a cable and stays tight right to the point where your hands meet. If you train in a gym without a free pulley, the pec deck is the closest machine match. If you only own dumbbells, an incline or flat dumbbell fly paired with a squeeze press covers both the stretch and the squeeze.

Can I replace cable flyes with dumbbell flyes?

Yes, as long as you know what changes. Dumbbells load your chest hardest at the bottom of the rep, in the stretch, and almost not at all at the top, because gravity pulls straight down through your arms once they are vertical. Stop each rep a little short of vertical to keep tension on, or follow the flyes with a squeeze press to train the part of the range they miss.

Are band flyes as good as cable flyes for building muscle?

For most home lifters, yes. A meta-analysis comparing elastic bands with weight machines and dumbbells found similar strength gains between the two. The catch with bands is loading: the jumps between band strengths are bigger than the 2.5kg to 5kg steps on a cable stack, so you progress by adding reps, doubling up bands or stepping further from the anchor.

What can I do instead of a low-to-high cable fly?

An incline dumbbell fly on a bench set to around 30 degrees is the simplest swap. With bands, anchor them low behind you and sweep your hands up and together to around chin height. Both shift the work towards the upper chest, as the cable version does.

How do I do a chest fly with no equipment?

Use a towel or two sliders on a smooth floor and do a kneeling or full slider fly, letting your hands glide out and pulling them back together. A deficit push-up between two chairs or stacks of books is the other option: it is a press rather than a fly, but it gives you the deep stretch that flyes are often used for.

Related guides

Best Exercise is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.co.uk. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no extra cost to you and never influences our independent reviews or rankings.