Skip to content
Workouts

Skull Crusher Alternative: 8 Swaps for Every Situation

Nadia Popescu

By Nadia Popescu, Strength & Conditioning Writer · Updated 22 November 2026

The best skull crusher alternative for most people is an overhead triceps extension, done with a cable or a dumbbell, because it keeps the long head of the triceps under stretch the same way a skull crusher does. If elbow pain is why you are swapping, start with a neutral-grip dumbbell extension or a cable rope pushdown. If you lack an EZ bar or a bench, a dumbbell or floor version does the job. Below are eight alternatives grouped by situation, how to do each one, what each keeps and loses compared with the original, and a quick table to help you choose.

What the skull crusher actually trains

A skull crusher is a lying triceps extension: you lie on a bench, hold an EZ bar or dumbbells above your chest, and bend only at the elbows to lower the weight towards your forehead or just behind your head. It trains all three heads of the triceps.

  • Long head. The only head that crosses the shoulder as well as the elbow. Because your upper arms sit slightly back past vertical in a well-performed skull crusher, the long head is stretched more than it would be with your arms at your sides.
  • Lateral head. The outer part of the horseshoe shape, working hard as you lock out.
  • Medial head. Sits underneath the other two and works on every elbow extension, whatever the arm position.

That long-head stretch is what makes skull crushers so useful for arm size, and it matters when you pick a replacement. In a 12-week study by Maeo and colleagues, the arm trained with overhead cable extensions gained noticeably more triceps volume than the arm trained with pushdowns, with the biggest difference in the long head (Maeo et al., overhead vs neutral arm triceps training). The study was small and compared two different exercises, so treat it as a strong hint rather than settled fact. The practical takeaway still holds: if you drop skull crushers, keep at least one exercise where your arms are up by your head.

Why people swap skull crushers out

Elbow pain. This is the big one. A heavy straight bar locks your wrists in one position and puts a lot of stress through the elbow at the bottom of the rep. Plenty of lifters get a nagging ache on the back or inside of the elbow after months of heavy skull crushers.

No EZ bar or bench. Training at home with only dumbbells or a cable station is common. If you are deciding whether to buy a bar, our guide to EZ bar weight explains what you would actually be lifting.

No spotter. Lowering a loaded bar towards your face when you are close to failure is a genuine risk on your own. Several of the swaps below let you fail safely.

Shoulder discomfort. Some people find the arm-back position uncomfortable at the shoulder. Pushdowns and presses keep the upper arm lower.

The 8 best skull crusher alternatives

Elbow-friendly swaps

1. Neutral-grip dumbbell skull crusher

The closest like-for-like swap and our top elbow-friendly pick.

How to do it: Lie on a bench with a dumbbell in each hand, palms facing each other. Start with your arms straight above your shoulders, then let them lean back a few degrees. Bend at the elbows and lower the dumbbells beside your head until your forearms pass parallel to the floor, then press back up without letting your elbows flare.

Keeps: The same lying position, the same long-head stretch and the same range of motion. Loses: Some loading potential, since two dumbbells are harder to control than one bar. Fine for 10 to 15 reps, awkward for heavy sets of 6.

The neutral grip lets your wrists and elbows find their own path, which is usually why it feels better than a straight or even an EZ bar.

2. Cable rope pushdown

How to do it: Attach a rope to a high pulley. Stand tall, pin your elbows to your sides and push the rope down until your arms are straight, pulling the rope ends apart slightly at the bottom. Control it back up until your forearms are just above parallel. Our full tricep pushdown guide covers set-up in detail.

Keeps: All three heads, smooth constant tension from the cable, and the easiest load to control. Loses: The long-head stretch, because your arms stay by your sides.

This is the safest option when your elbows are grumbling, and it is easy to go to failure without a spotter.

Overhead swaps (to keep the long-head stretch)

3. Overhead cable extension

How to do it: Set a rope on a low or mid pulley, face away from the stack and bring your hands behind your head with your elbows pointing forward. Lean forward slightly, keep your upper arms still and extend until your arms are straight overhead, then lower slowly into a deep stretch. More detail is in our overhead tricep extension guide.

Keeps: The long-head stretch, even more than a skull crusher, plus constant cable tension. Loses: Some stability. Shoulder mobility limits how comfortably you can get into position.

This is the exercise used in the overhead arm of the Maeo study, which makes it our pick for size.

4. Seated overhead dumbbell extension

How to do it: Sit on a bench with back support, holding one dumbbell vertically in both hands by the inner plate. Press it overhead, then lower it behind your head by bending only at the elbows. Keep your elbows pointing forward rather than flaring wide, and press back up.

Keeps: The long-head stretch, with only one dumbbell needed. Loses: Tension near lockout, as the load stacks over your joints at the top.

The best no-bench option too: you can do it standing.

5. Resistance band overhead extension

How to do it: Stand on one end of a band or anchor it low behind you. Hold the other end behind your head and extend your arms overhead.

Keeps: The overhead position and the stretch, and it travels anywhere. Loses: Load at the stretched position, because bands are lightest where the triceps is longest. Good for high reps and warm-ups, weaker for building size on its own.

Heavy compound swaps

6. JM press

How to do it: Lie on a bench with a barbell or Smith machine bar, hands about shoulder width or a touch closer. Lower the bar towards your upper chest or chin by letting your elbows travel forward and down, as if blending a close-grip bench press with a skull crusher. Stop when your forearms meet your biceps, then press back up.

Keeps: Heavy loading on all three heads and plenty of lateral and medial head work. Loses: Some long-head stretch, and it takes a few sessions to learn the groove.

Good for strength-focused lifters who want something heavier than an isolation move. A Smith machine makes it safer without a spotter.

7. Close-grip bench press or floor press

How to do it: Take a barbell or dumbbells with hands just inside shoulder width, keep your elbows tucked at around 30 to 45 degrees and press. For a floor press, lie on the floor so your upper arms stop at the ground each rep. See our close-grip bench press guide for full form cues.

Keeps: Heavy triceps loading and lockout strength, which carries over to your bench press. Loses: Isolation, because your chest and front delts share the work, and most of the long-head stretch.

The floor press is very joint-friendly because the floor caps the range, and it needs no bench and no spotter.

8. Tate press

How to do it: Lie on a bench holding two dumbbells over your chest with palms facing your feet and the dumbbell heads touching. Bend your elbows outwards so the dumbbells lower towards your chest, then press back up by extending the elbows.

Keeps: A lying elbow extension with strong lateral and medial head work and a hard lockout. Loses: The long-head stretch, and the elbows-out pattern does not suit everyone. Use light weights first.

Bodyweight backup

If you have no weights at all, bench dips and diamond push-ups both load the triceps. Diamond push-ups are kinder on the shoulders. Tricep dips give a strong overload but put the shoulder in a deep extended position, so skip them if your shoulders complain. Neither replaces the long-head stretch of a skull crusher.

Why mixing positions works

The three triceps heads do not behave as a single unit: in one EMG study, the long head fatigued earliest and the medial head last during the same task (triceps head fatigue study). One overhead exercise plus one pushdown or press covers the muscle more completely than any single swap.

Pick by situation

Your situationBest swapBackup
Elbow painNeutral-grip dumbbell skull crusherCable rope pushdown
Want maximum arm sizeOverhead cable extensionSeated overhead dumbbell extension
No EZ barNeutral-grip dumbbell skull crusherSeated overhead dumbbell extension
No benchSeated or standing overhead dumbbell extensionClose-grip floor press
No spotterCable rope pushdownClose-grip floor press
Want to lift heavyJM press (Smith machine)Close-grip bench press
Training at home with no weightsResistance band overhead extensionDiamond push-up

A simple weekly plan for most people: one overhead extension for 3 sets of 10 to 15 reps, plus a pushdown or close-grip press for 3 sets of 8 to 12. If you train at home, a pair of adjustable dumbbells covers swaps 1, 4, 7 and 8, and a cable machine covers swaps 2 and 3.

Common mistakes

Swapping to pushdowns only. Pushdowns are great, but if they are your only triceps exercise you lose the long-head stretch that made skull crushers worth doing. Keep one overhead movement.

Flaring the elbows on overhead work. Letting your elbows drift wide turns an extension into a sloppy press and shifts stress to the shoulder. Keep them pointing forward.

Going too heavy too soon. If elbow pain sent you looking for alternatives, loading a new exercise heavily straight away often brings the pain back. Start with moderate weights and 12 to 15 reps for two or three weeks.

Rushing the lowering phase. Dropping into the stretch quickly loads the elbow tendon hard. Take two to three seconds to lower on every rep.

Moving the upper arm. On extensions and pushdowns, the upper arm should stay still. If your shoulders swing to move the weight, it is too heavy.

Ignoring pain. A muscular burn is normal. Sharp pain at the elbow joint is not. If an exercise hurts in that way even with light weight, drop it and pick another from the table above. Persistent pain is worth checking with a physiotherapist.

Recommended reads

  1. Skull crushers: how to do them properly
  2. Overhead tricep extension guide
  3. Tricep pushdown alternatives
  4. The best tricep exercises
  5. The best cable machines in the UK

Frequently asked questions

What is the best skull crusher alternative?

For most people it is the overhead triceps extension, with a cable or a dumbbell. It keeps the long head in a stretched position like the skull crusher does, and research suggests overhead extensions build more triceps size than pushdowns. If your elbows hurt, start with a neutral-grip dumbbell extension or a rope pushdown instead.

What can I do instead of skull crushers if my elbows hurt?

Try a neutral-grip dumbbell skull crusher (palms facing each other), a cable rope pushdown or a close-grip floor press. All three are gentler on the elbow than a straight-bar skull crusher. Use moderate weights, 10 to 15 reps and a slow lowering phase, and stop any exercise that causes sharp pain rather than a muscular burn.

Can I do skull crushers without a bench?

Yes. Lie on the floor and do them as a floor skull crusher, or switch to a standing or seated overhead dumbbell extension, which needs no bench at all. The floor version slightly shortens the range at the bottom, but it still trains all three heads of the triceps well.

Are dumbbell skull crushers better than EZ bar skull crushers?

Neither is strictly better. Dumbbells let each arm work on its own and let you turn your palms to face each other, which many people find kinder on the elbows and wrists. An EZ bar lets you load heavier and progress in smaller steps. If the bar version aggravates your elbows, the dumbbell version is the first swap to try.

Do pushdowns work the same muscles as skull crushers?

Pushdowns work all three heads of the triceps, but with your arms by your sides the long head is shorter and less stretched than in a skull crusher. They are an excellent elbow-friendly option, though pairing them with an overhead extension gives you closer to the full training effect of a skull crusher.

Related guides

Best Exercise is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.co.uk. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no extra cost to you and never influences our independent reviews or rankings.