Cable Fly Alternative: 8 Swaps for Dumbbells, Bands and Bodyweight
The best cable fly alternatives by equipment: dumbbell, band, pec deck, rings, plates and bodyweight. How to do each, what it keeps and what it loses vs the cable.
By Nadia Popescu, Strength & Conditioning Writer · Updated 22 November 2026
A Smith machine split squat is a static split-stance squat done under a Smith bar: one foot forward, one foot back, both planted for the whole set while you lower straight down and drive back up. Because the bar runs on fixed vertical rails, the whole exercise comes down to where you put your front foot relative to that line, and once you get that right it becomes one of the easiest ways to load a single leg heavily without worrying about balance. Below is how to set it up, the cues that matter, the front-foot-elevated and Bulgarian versions, and how to programme it.
If you're brand new to the machine (hooks, safeties, bar weight), read how to use a Smith machine first. If you'd rather step in and out of each rep, our Smith machine lunge guide covers the reverse lunge version.
With dumbbells or a free barbell, your body finds the balance point for you: if your weight drifts towards your toes, the load drifts with it and you correct. A Smith bar can't do that. It travels straight up and down on the same line every rep, so your body has to arrange itself around the bar rather than the other way round.
Get the front foot wrong and you feel it straight away. Too close to the bar line and your front knee shoots well past your toes, the heel lifts, and the knee takes the whole load. Too far in front and the bar ends up behind your centre of mass at the bottom, which feels like being pulled backwards and puts strain on your lower back as you try to stay upright.
The target is simple to describe: at the bottom of the rep, the bar should sit over the middle of your front foot, with your front shin vertical or leaning a little forward. For most people that means the front foot lands roughly 15 to 30cm in front of the bar's path, depending on leg length and how deep you go. Find it with an empty bar, then mark the floor with a bit of tape or note which plate on the frame lines up with your toes.
Test your stance in a single rep
Do one slow rep with the empty bar and pause at the bottom. Front heel lifting? Move the front foot forward. Feel like you're tipping backwards? Bring it back. You should feel pressure through the whole front foot, slightly more towards the heel.
The front leg does the bulk of the work. Its quadriceps straighten the knee and its glute max extends the hip out of the bottom, with the adductors (inner thigh) helping a lot in the deeper part of the rep. The hamstrings assist at the hip, and the calf of the front leg helps stabilise the ankle.
The back leg isn't idle: its hip flexors and quad get a stretch under load, which is why a heavy set of split squats leaves the front of your back thigh feeling tight. Your core braces throughout, though less than with dumbbells or a free bar, because the rails cancel out a lot of the balance demand.
You can shift the emphasis. A 2023 study of split squats at four step lengths found that longer steps mainly increased hip extensor activity (glutes and hamstrings) while having limited effect on the knee extensors, and suggested a step equal to leg length suits healthy adults for strength training. So:
Free-weight split squats are great, and you should still do them. The Smith version has a few specific advantages, though.
You can load it heavier, earlier. With dumbbells your grip and balance often give out before your legs do. With a barbell split squat, a wobble at the bottom of a hard rep can end the set. On a Smith machine, the legs are usually the limiting factor, which is what you want when the goal is building leg muscle.
Safer to push close to failure. The safeties catch the bar and you can rehook it at any point in the rep. That makes it a good option for training alone at home.
Less load through your spine for a lot of leg work. Single-leg squatting lets you work each leg hard with a much lighter bar than a back squat. In a 2018 study of trained men, single-leg barbell squats with a far lighter load produced similar hamstring, calf, hip and abdominal muscle activity to bilateral squats, and the authors pointed to the lower spinal loading as a reason to use them for people with back pain. The Smith version keeps that advantage and removes some of the balance demand.
Easy to repeat. The bar path is identical every time, so if you note your foot position, every session starts from the same place and your progress numbers mean something.
The trade-off is that you train less balance and stabiliser work. Mix it with dumbbell or bodyweight split squats rather than replacing them completely.
Stand your front foot on a low step or a 5cm to 10cm plate or platform. Raising the front foot lets your back knee drop lower relative to your front hip, so you get more range of motion at the front hip and knee without needing the back knee to go through the floor.
It's a good choice if you want more depth and more stretch on the front glute and quad, or if regular split squats feel cramped at the bottom. Use about 10 to 20% less weight than your normal split squat to start, and set the safeties slightly lower than usual since you'll travel further. Recheck front foot position: you'll usually need it a little further forward. If you like the deep knee-forward position, our ATG split squat guide covers a related progression in more detail.
Place a flat bench behind you, about one leg-length from the bar line, and rest the top of your back foot (laces down) on it. Then set your front foot so the bar lands over its middle at the bottom.
Because the back foot is up on the bench, more of your bodyweight and the bar's load shifts onto the front leg. That makes it harder per kilo than a standard split squat, so drop the load noticeably the first time. The setup also takes a little longer: the bench has to stay put, and you need room inside the frame for both the bench and your stance. Measure your machine before you buy a bench if space is tight.
For the free-weight version and its foot-placement cues, see our full guide to the Bulgarian split squat.
Front foot too close to the bar. This is the big one. The knee shoots forward, the heel lifts and the knee takes the strain. Move the foot forward until your heel stays planted.
Stance too narrow side to side. Feet in a single line feel wobbly even on a Smith, because the rails only help with the bar, not your hips. Keep about hip-width apart.
Pushing off the back leg. If your back calf and quad are burning more than your front leg, you're cheating with the back foot. Shift your weight forward slightly and think about lifting the front leg up, not the back leg.
Bouncing the back knee off the floor. It feels like a stretch reflex; it's mostly impact. Stop a few centimetres short, or lower the safeties so the bar catches you first.
Leaning back to stay under the bar. If you have to lean your torso backwards to keep the bar balanced, the front foot is too far forward. Bring it back a few centimetres.
Skipping the empty-bar test. Every Smith machine is slightly different, and some have angled rails. Five minutes finding your stance will save a lot of grumpy knees.
The split squat works best in the moderate-to-higher rep range, partly because heavy singles on one leg are awkward to set up and recover from.
| Goal | Sets x reps | Rest | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Muscle building | 3 to 4 x 8 to 12 per leg | 90 seconds | Take the last set close to failure |
| Strength | 3 to 5 x 5 to 8 per leg | 2 to 3 minutes | Use the standard (not Bulgarian) version |
| Learning or rehab-style work | 2 to 3 x 10 to 15 per leg | 60 seconds | Light load, slow 3-second lowering |
Put it after a main bilateral lift such as the Smith machine squat, or use it as the main leg exercise if squats bother your back. Pair it with a hinge like the Smith machine RDL to cover the backs of your legs. Twice a week is plenty for most people.
Progress by adding reps first, then weight. Once you hit the top of your rep range on all sets with clean form, add 2.5kg to 5kg total. Always start with your weaker leg and match the reps on the stronger side, which helps even out any imbalance over time.
No: any split squat variation builds the same muscles. But if you train at home and want to load single-leg work heavily on your own, a Smith machine is one of the most useful pieces of kit you can own. Our roundup of the best Smith machines in the UK compares the main options, and the Marcy MD-9010 Smith machine review looks at one of the more popular home models. For planning space and budget, start with our home gym hub.
Roughly 15 to 30cm in front of the line the bar travels down, so that at the bottom your front shin is vertical or tipped slightly forward and the bar sits over the middle of your front foot. If your front heel peels up, move the foot forward. If the bar feels like it is dragging you backwards out of the hole, move it back. Adjust 5cm at a time with an empty bar.
It is easier to balance, because the rails stop the bar drifting sideways or forwards, and you have no grip limit. That makes it easier to load heavy and push close to failure. It is not easier on the legs: with the same effort the front leg works just as hard, and most people end up using more weight than they could hold in dumbbells.
It varies by machine. Many home Smith machines have a counterbalanced or light bar, while commercial ones can be anywhere from roughly 7kg to 20kg. Check the manufacturer's spec or the label on the frame, and log your lifts on the same machine so your numbers stay comparable.
Yes. Put a flat bench behind you, rest the top of your back foot on it, and set your front foot far enough forward that the bar lands over the middle of that foot at the bottom. It takes a few test reps to find the spot, so start with the empty bar and set the safety stops just below your lowest point.
Both, and you can tilt the balance with stance length and torso angle. A shorter stance with an upright torso keeps more work on the quads. A longer stance with a slight forward lean from the hips moves more of it to the glutes and hamstrings. Research on split squat step length found that longer steps mainly raised hip extensor activity.
The best cable fly alternatives by equipment: dumbbell, band, pec deck, rings, plates and bodyweight. How to do each, what it keeps and what it loses vs the cable.
A free 8-week dumbbell workout plan: a 3-day full body routine for beginners and a 4-day upper/lower split, with sets, reps, rest and weekly progression.
A glute and hamstring workout you can use today: a gym session and a home version with dumbbells, kettlebell or bands, plus sets, reps, rest and an 8-week plan.
The best skull crusher alternatives for sore elbows, no EZ bar, no bench or no spotter. How to do each one, what it keeps and loses, and which to pick.
Best Exercise is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.co.uk. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no extra cost to you and never influences our independent reviews or rankings.