Huel Alternative: Cheaper, Higher Protein and Less Processed Options
Looking for a Huel alternative? We match the best options to your reason for leaving, from cheaper and lower calorie shakes to milk-based drinks and a DIY recipe.
By Declan Hallwood, Nutrition & Supplements Editor · Updated 17 November 2026
Huel Black Edition Ready-to-drink is the better buy for most people. A chocolate bottle gives you 35g of plant protein in 400kcal with just 5.8g of sugars, and at around £38.98 for 12 on Amazon UK it costs about £3.25 a bottle. yfood's Classic drinks are bigger (500kcal), creamier and much richer in calcium, but they cost about £4.00 a bottle on Amazon, carry 30g of protein and are made from milk, so they're out for vegans and anyone with a dairy allergy. Standard Huel Ready-to-drink is the cheapest of the three per bottle, but at 20g of protein it trails both on the number most people care about.
Where these numbers come from
Nutrition figures are taken from the nutrition panels on Huel's Black Edition Ready-to-drink page, Huel's Ready-to-drink page and yfood's Classic Choco page, all checked on 17 November 2026. We've used the chocolate flavour of each so the comparison is fair; other flavours vary a little. Prices are Amazon UK prices at the time of writing. We haven't run our own taste panel, so taste notes below come from owner reviews, not from us.
| Per 500ml bottle (chocolate) | Huel Black Edition RTD | Huel Ready-to-drink | yfood Classic Choco |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calories | 400kcal | 400kcal | 500kcal |
| Protein | 35g | 20g | 30g |
| Carbohydrate | 23g | 32g | 37g |
| of which sugars | 5.8g | 2.4g | 22g |
| Fibre | 6.6g | 8.4g | 9.2g |
| Fat | 17g | 19g | 24g |
| of which saturates | 6.0g | 4.4g | 5.6g |
| Salt | 0.96g | 0.90g | 0.83g |
| Vitamins and minerals | 26 | 26 | 26 |
| Calcium | 260mg (33% NRV) | 260mg (33% NRV) | 800mg (100% NRV) |
| Main protein source | Pea and faba bean | Pea | Milk and milk protein |
| Vegan | Yes | Yes | No |
| Lactose-free | Yes (no dairy) | Yes (no dairy) | Yes (lactase added) |
| Sweetener | Stevia | Sucralose | Sucralose |
| Amazon UK pack | 12 x 500ml, around £38.98 | 8 x 500ml, around £25.34 | 8 x 500ml, around £31.98 |
| Price per bottle | about £3.25 | about £3.17 | about £4.00 |
One small note on the Amazon packs: the 8-bottle Huel Ready-to-drink listing is vanilla, and the yfood listing lets you pick any eight from its Classic flavours. The nutrition above is chocolate for all three because that's the one flavour they share.
This is the biggest difference, and it's why the verdict goes to Huel's Black Edition rather than Huel generally.
Black Edition packs 35g of protein into 400kcal, which works out at 8.8g per 100kcal. yfood Classic Choco gives 30g in 500kcal, or 6g per 100kcal. Standard Huel Ready-to-drink sits at the bottom with 20g in 400kcal (5g per 100kcal). If you're using a shake to hit a daily protein target after training, Black Edition gets you there with fewer calories, and that matters if you're trying to lose fat without losing muscle.
The protein source differs too. Both Huel bottles are built on pea protein (Black Edition adds faba bean), while yfood uses semi-skimmed milk plus added milk protein. For most people the real deciding factor is simply whether you eat dairy at all.
One thing to watch: yfood's Amazon listing title says "34g protein", but the Classic Choco label on yfood's own site reads 30g. Flavours vary, so check the label of the one you actually order.
yfood bottles are 500kcal, a quarter more than Huel's 400kcal. That's not better or worse on its own. If you're replacing a proper lunch and you're a bigger or more active person, 500kcal will probably hold you longer. If you're in a calorie deficit, 400kcal is easier to fit into the day, and one yfood owner on Amazon mentions drinking three quarters of a bottle at a time for exactly that reason.
Meal replacement drinks can help with weight loss when they're part of a structured plan. A 2019 systematic review and meta-analysis of 23 trials found that programmes using meal replacements led to more weight loss at one year than comparison diets, with the biggest gap when people also had extra support (Astbury et al., Obesity Reviews). That applies to the category, not to either brand specifically.
On paper yfood looks sugary: 22g per bottle against 5.8g for Black Edition and 2.4g for standard Huel. The context changes that picture. yfood says there's no added sugar in Classic Choco, and the ingredients back it up: the sugar comes from the milk, and the sweetness boost comes from sucralose.
The NHS is clear that sugar found naturally in milk doesn't count as free sugar, the type adults are told to keep under 30g a day (NHS guide to sugar in your diet). yfood's 4.4g of sugars per 100ml also sits under the NHS "low sugar" threshold of 5g per 100g. So it's fine for most people. If you're watching total carbs or blood sugar closely, though, Black Edition's 23g of carbs and 5.8g of sugars make it the easier fit.
yfood edges fibre with 9.2g a bottle, ahead of standard Huel (8.4g) and Black Edition (6.6g). The gap is under 3g, so it shouldn't decide your purchase.
Fat is highest in yfood at 24g, largely because the bottle has 100 more calories to fill. Saturates are close across the board (4.4g to 6.0g), with Black Edition slightly highest thanks to coconut milk powder and MCT powder.
All three list 26 vitamins and minerals. The gap that stands out is calcium: one yfood bottle gives 800mg, 100% of the reference intake, because it's milk-based. Huel's bottles give 260mg (33%). If you don't eat much dairy and you're drinking these daily, that's worth knowing. Black Edition does hit 100% of vitamin D per bottle, and so does standard Huel.
Using the Amazon UK prices at the time of writing:
| Pack | Price | Per bottle | Per 100kcal | Per 10g protein |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Huel Black Edition RTD (12 x 500ml) | around £38.98 | £3.25 | 81p | 93p |
| Huel Ready-to-drink (8 x 500ml) | around £25.34 | £3.17 | 79p | £1.58 |
| yfood Classic (8 x 500ml) | around £31.98 | £4.00 | 80p | £1.33 |
Per calorie, the three are almost identical. Per gram of protein, Black Edition is the clear winner, costing about 30% less per 10g than yfood and roughly 40% less than standard Huel.
Amazon isn't always the cheapest route. On Huel's own site, Black Edition is £3.42 a bottle on subscription and standard Ready-to-drink £3.17. yfood's site lists a 6-pack of Classic Choco at £3.49 a bottle one-off or £2.97 on subscription, which makes yfood direct noticeably cheaper than its Amazon price. If you settle on yfood for daily use, the subscription is worth a look.
Check Huel Black Edition RTD (12 x 500ml) on Amazonaround £39We haven't taste-tested these ourselves, so this is what owners consistently say in Amazon reviews.
yfood's reviews lean heavily on "creamy" and "like a milkshake". That makes sense given it's milk-based with more fat per bottle. Its Amazon listing has far fewer ratings than Huel's, so treat that consensus with some caution.
Most Huel Black Edition chocolate owners like the taste, though a minority find the texture slightly grainy. Standard Huel Ready-to-drink gets mixed comments on texture (smooth for some, lumpy for others). Pea-protein drinks do tend to be thinner and earthier than dairy ones, and if you've only ever had milk-based shakes that's the adjustment to expect.
All three are shelf-stable. Huel says to refrigerate once opened and finish within 12 hours, and both brands taste best cold.
Pick Huel Black Edition RTD if you want the most protein per calorie, you're vegan or dairy-free, or you're watching carbs and sugar. It's the strongest all-rounder here and, on Amazon, cheaper per bottle than yfood too.
Pick yfood Classic if you eat dairy, prefer a creamier, milkshake-style drink, or want a bigger 500kcal meal that keeps you going longer. It's also the pick if you're short on calcium. Lactose intolerant? The Classic range is labelled lactose-free, but it still contains milk, so skip it if you have a milk allergy.
Pick standard Huel Ready-to-drink if price per bottle is the priority and you don't need much protein from it, for example as an occasional meal on a travel day. Most regular users will be better off paying a few pence more for Black Edition.
Vegan but like the yfood brand? yfood sells a separate Vegan range on its UK site. Vegan Choco uses soy, pea and sunflower protein and lists 28g of protein and 500kcal per bottle. It isn't part of the Classic Amazon multipack below, and soy rules it out for anyone with a soy allergy.
Check yfood Classic drinks (pick any 8 x 500ml) on Amazonaround £32If you're still deciding between Huel formats, our Huel powder vs Ready-to-drink comparison shows how much cheaper the powder is per meal. For a closer look at either brand on its own, see our Huel review and our breakdown of whether yfood is healthy.
Huel Black Edition Ready-to-drink beats yfood for most people. It gives you 5g more protein in 100 fewer calories, a fraction of the sugar, a fully vegan recipe and, on Amazon UK, a lower price per bottle. yfood is a well-made drink with real strengths: it's creamier, more filling at 500kcal and packed with calcium. Choose it if you eat dairy and want a bigger meal in a bottle, and buy direct on subscription to bring the cost down. Standard Huel Ready-to-drink is only worth choosing over Black Edition if you're counting every penny and protein isn't the point.
For more meal replacement and protein guides, browse our nutrition hub.
For most people, Huel Black Edition Ready-to-drink is the better buy. On the chocolate labels it gives 35g of protein in 400kcal against 30g in 500kcal for yfood Classic Choco, with 5.8g of sugars against 22g, and on Amazon UK it works out cheaper per bottle (about £3.25 against about £4.00 at the time of writing). yfood is the better pick if you want a bigger 500kcal meal, a creamier milkshake-style drink or a lot more calcium.
The Classic yfood drinks are not vegan. Classic Choco is made with semi-skimmed milk and milk protein. yfood does sell a separate Vegan range on its UK site (Vegan Choco uses soy, pea and sunflower protein), but the Classic multipack on Amazon is milk-based. Every Huel Ready-to-drink is vegan.
yfood labels its Classic drinks lactose-free: the recipe includes the lactase enzyme, which breaks the milk sugar down. That makes it suitable for many people with lactose intolerance, but it still contains milk, so it is not suitable for anyone with a milk allergy. Huel contains no dairy at all.
It depends which Huel. Huel Black Edition Ready-to-drink has 35g per bottle, yfood Classic Choco has 30g, and standard Huel Ready-to-drink has 20g. Per 100kcal, Black Edition gives 8.8g, yfood 6g and standard Huel 5g.
yfood Classic Choco lists 22g of sugars per bottle, but yfood states there's no added sugar: the sugars come from the milk. The NHS says sugar naturally found in milk does not count as free sugar. At 4.4g per 100ml it still falls under the NHS low-sugar threshold of 5g per 100g. Huel Black Edition chocolate lists 5.8g per bottle, partly from coconut sugar.
Not on Amazon UK. At the time of writing, an 8-pack of yfood is around £31.98 (about £4.00 a bottle), a 12-pack of Huel Black Edition is around £38.98 (about £3.25 a bottle) and an 8-pack of standard Huel Ready-to-drink is around £25.34 (about £3.17 a bottle). Because yfood bottles carry 500kcal rather than 400kcal, the cost per calorie ends up almost identical across all three.
Looking for a Huel alternative? We match the best options to your reason for leaving, from cheaper and lower calorie shakes to milk-based drinks and a DIY recipe.

Our Huel Daily Greens review covers the 91-ingredient formula, probiotic doses, vitamin levels, taste and price per serving, plus what greens powders can't do.

Our Huel review of the Black Edition powder: 40g protein, 9.7g fibre and 400kcal per meal for about £1.99, plus Ready-to-drink, taste reports, cost and who it suits.
Is Huel healthy? Our verdict: fine for one or two meals a day for most healthy adults, not as a long-term total diet. Nutrients, the ultra-processed debate, sweeteners, gas, salt and who should be careful.
Best Exercise is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.co.uk. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no extra cost to you and never influences our independent reviews or rankings.