
Huel Daily Greens Review: A Cheaper AG1 Rival, With Caveats
Our Huel Daily Greens review covers the 91-ingredient formula, probiotic doses, vitamin levels, taste and price per serving, plus what greens powders can't do.
By Declan Hallwood, Nutrition & Supplements Editor · Updated 17 November 2026
People rarely go looking for a Huel alternative because Huel is bad. They go looking because one specific thing about it doesn't suit them: the price creeps up once you're on two meals a day, the plant protein taste isn't for everyone, or the calorie count is too high for a cut. So rather than ranking a list of shakes, this guide works through the five most common reasons for leaving Huel and names a real alternative for each. Prices and nutrition figures come from the brands' own pages and Amazon UK listings checked on 17 November 2026.
If you haven't settled on whether Huel suits you in the first place, start with our Huel review and our look at whether Huel is good for you.
You need a baseline before you can call anything cheaper or higher protein. Huel's standard Powder is a vegan shake built on oats, pea protein, flaxseed, brown rice protein and tapioca. According to Huel's UK product page, one meal is two scoops (100g) mixed with 500ml of water, giving 400kcal and 30g of protein. A 17-meal bag costs £30 as a one-off order (£1.76 per meal) or £27 on subscription (£1.59 per meal).
That's genuinely cheap for 400kcal of complete nutrition. It matters, because several "Huel alternatives" you'll see recommended cost more per meal, not less.
| Option | Format | Calories per serving | Protein per serving | Price per serving |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Huel Powder | Vegan powder | 400kcal | 30g | £1.76 (£1.59 subscribed) |
| Huel Diet | Vegan powder | 200kcal | 20g | £1.11 (£1.00 subscribed) |
| yfood Classic | Milk-based bottle | 500kcal | 30g | £3.49 direct, about £4.00 on Amazon |
| Protein Works Diet Meal 360 Gold | Powder | See pack | See pack | About £1.44 on Amazon |
| Homemade shake (below) | DIY | About 670kcal | About 45g | About £1.50 to £1.80 |
Huel Powder and Diet figures are from Huel's site, yfood's from its UK site, and Amazon prices were correct at the time of writing. The homemade figures are our own estimates.
Honestly, it's hard to beat Huel Powder on price per 400kcal. Ready-to-drink bottles from any brand cost roughly double. So "cheaper" really means one of three things.
Make it yourself. The homemade shake further down this page costs about the same as Huel per serving but delivers more calories and far more protein, which makes it cheaper per gram of protein. You give up the convenience and the full micronutrient profile.
Go smaller. Lower calorie powders cost less per serving because there's less in the scoop. Huel Diet comes in 34-meal bags at £37.80 one-off (£1.11 per meal) or £34 on subscription. On Amazon, Protein Works Diet Meal 360 Gold costs around £21.57 at the time of writing for a 1kg bag of 15 meals, which works out at about £1.44 per serving. It's sold as a diet meal replacement, so treat it as a lighter meal rather than a straight Huel swap, and check the label for the calorie count of the flavour you buy.
Check the Protein Works Diet Meal 360 Gold price on Amazon£21.57Buy direct and subscribe. If you like Huel and only want to spend less, the 10% subscription discount takes Powder to £1.59 per meal. That alone may be enough.
You'll also see Jimmy Joy's Plenny Shake mentioned as a budget vegan option. It's sold mainly through the brand's own site rather than Amazon UK, and we couldn't confirm its current UK pricing when writing this, so compare it on the day before you switch.
Huel is vegan, and some people simply prefer milk protein: the texture is creamier and the taste is less earthy. Others want more than 30g of protein in a meal.
yfood is the best-known milk-based alternative in the UK. Its UK site lists 500kcal and 30g of protein in each 500ml bottle, describes the drinks as lactose-free and milk-based, and prices a six-pack of Classic Choco at £20.94 (£3.49 per meal). The Amazon listing for the eight-bottle pack quotes 34g of protein per bottle, which suggests a newer recipe; check the label on what arrives. That pack costs around £31.98 at the time of writing, or about £4.00 a bottle.
Check the yfood 8 x 500ml price on Amazon£31.98We compare the two head to head in Huel vs yfood.
If protein is the priority and you don't mind staying plant based, Huel's own Black Edition lists 40g protein and 400kcal per meal from £1.79 on Huel's site. That's still Huel, of course. For the highest protein per pound, the homemade shake with whey and milk wins comfortably.
Huel is a processed food by any reasonable definition: powdered, blended and fortified. Some people would rather eat ingredients they recognise, and that's a fair preference whatever the debate about processing.
The whole-food route is a homemade shake, or simply a quick meal. Overnight oats with Greek yoghurt and fruit, or eggs on toast, take five minutes and need no shaker. You lose the guaranteed 26 vitamins and minerals Huel adds, so if you're replacing more than one meal a day, a varied diet or a basic multivitamin fills the gap.
Taste is personal, but a common complaint about Huel Powder is a slightly gritty, oaty texture. Two fixes are worth trying before you give up on the format: use cold milk instead of water, and blend rather than shake.
If you want zero preparation, a ready-to-drink bottle is the answer. yfood is the main non-Huel option on Amazon UK, and its flavours lean sweet and milkshake-like. Huel also sells its own ready-to-drink range; our Huel powder vs ready-to-drink guide covers whether the convenience is worth the higher cost. Either way, expect to pay roughly £3.25 to £4.00 a bottle rather than under £2 for powder.
At 400kcal, a Huel Powder meal is a proper lunch. If you're using shakes to lose weight, that may be more than you want.
Huel Diet halves it: 200kcal and 20g protein per meal, according to Huel. Protein Works Diet Meal 360 is a cheaper diet-style alternative on Amazon. The evidence for this approach is reasonable rather than spectacular. A 2019 systematic review and meta-analysis of 23 trials found that diets including meal replacements led to about 1.44kg more weight loss at one year than other diets, and the gap grew to around 6kg when people also had enhanced support (systematic review in Obesity Reviews). In other words, the shakes help most when they're part of a plan, not a standalone fix.
Check the Huel Diet Powder price on Amazon£39.69Huel Diet costs around £39.69 on Amazon at the time of writing, slightly more than the £37.80 one-off price on Huel's own site.
This is the option we'd point most people towards if price per gram of protein matters. Blend everything for 30 seconds:
Using standard nutrition values (oats at roughly 370kcal and 12g protein per 100g, semi-skimmed milk at about 47kcal and 3.5g protein per 100ml), the shake comes to approximately:
| Nutrient | Approximate amount |
|---|---|
| Calories | 670kcal |
| Protein | 45g |
| Carbohydrate | 81g |
| Fat | 19g |
These are rough figures. Your brand of oats, whey and peanut butter will shift them a little. For a lighter version closer to Huel's 400kcal, use 40g oats, 250ml milk, the whey and half a banana, and drop the peanut butter: that lands at about 430kcal and 36g protein.
Cost-wise, a 1kg bag of unflavoured Impact Whey is around £32.38 on Amazon at the time of writing. Add supermarket oats, milk, a banana and peanut butter and we estimate the shake costs roughly £1.50 to £1.80. Our Myprotein Impact Whey review covers the powder in more detail.
Check the Myprotein Impact Whey 1kg price on Amazon£32.38The trade-off is real, though. This shake isn't fortified, so it won't give you the full vitamin and mineral spread that Huel guarantees, and it takes two minutes and a blender rather than ten seconds and a shaker.
Match it to your reason for leaving:
If your only gripe is cost and you otherwise like Huel, subscribing direct at £1.59 per meal is probably the simplest fix. Plenty of people who leave end up back on it for exactly that reason. You'll find more shake and protein guides in our nutrition hub.
A homemade shake of oats, milk, whey, banana and peanut butter works out at roughly £1.50 to £1.80 a serving, which is close to Huel Powder's £1.76 one-off price per meal but gives you more protein. If you want something ready made, Protein Works Diet Meal 360 Gold costs around £1.44 per meal on Amazon at the time of writing, and Huel's own Diet powder is £1.11 per meal bought direct, though both are smaller, lower calorie servings.
Yes. yfood's ready-to-drink meals are milk based (lactose free) with 500kcal and 30g of protein per 500ml bottle on the brand's UK site. A homemade shake made with milk and whey is another dairy-based route, and it's easy to push past 40g of protein per serving.
It depends on what you want. yfood is a ready-to-drink bottle, so it's more convenient and many people prefer the milky taste, but it costs about £3.49 a bottle direct against £1.76 for a Huel Powder meal. If price matters most, Huel Powder wins. If you never want to mix a shake, yfood is the easier choice.
You can make a filling homemade meal shake, but it won't match Huel's full vitamin and mineral profile unless you add a multivitamin. A blend of 60g oats, 300ml semi-skimmed milk, a scoop of whey, a banana and 15g peanut butter gives roughly 670kcal and 45g protein. Those figures are approximate and based on standard nutrition values.
Huel Diet is the obvious step down, with 200kcal and 20g protein per meal according to Huel. Protein Works Diet Meal 360 is a cheaper diet-style shake on Amazon. Research suggests meal replacements can help with weight loss when used as part of a structured diet, especially with support.

Our Huel Daily Greens review covers the 91-ingredient formula, probiotic doses, vitamin levels, taste and price per serving, plus what greens powders can't do.

Our Huel review of the Black Edition powder: 40g protein, 9.7g fibre and 400kcal per meal for about £1.99, plus Ready-to-drink, taste reports, cost and who it suits.
Huel vs yfood compared bottle for bottle: calories, protein, sugar, fibre, vitamins, vegan status and UK price per bottle, with a clear verdict on which to buy.
Is Huel healthy? Our verdict: fine for one or two meals a day for most healthy adults, not as a long-term total diet. Nutrients, the ultra-processed debate, sweeteners, gas, salt and who should be careful.
Best Exercise is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.co.uk. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no extra cost to you and never influences our independent reviews or rankings.