Skip to content
Home Gym

Garmin vs Fitbit: Which Should You Buy in the UK in 2026?

Paul Kendrick

By Paul Kendrick, Cardio & Endurance Editor · Updated 21 November 2026

Buy a Garmin if you run, cycle or hike and want a watch that lasts a week or two, records long GPS sessions and gives you recovery data without a monthly fee. Buy a Fitbit if your budget stops at around £100 to £150 and you mainly want steps, sleep and heart rate on a light band or simple watch. That's the short version, and it holds at nearly every price point. The longer one depends on which rung of each ladder you're standing on, because a £59 Inspire 3 and a £345 Venu 4 aren't really competing for the same buyer.

How we compared them

Battery, GPS and feature figures come from Google's UK Store spec pages, Garmin's product pages and owner's manuals, and our own reviews of each model. Fitbit prices are current Amazon UK figures; Garmin prices are the Amazon UK prices from our reviews and move often. We haven't worn a Garmin and a Fitbit side by side for this guide, so battery numbers are manufacturer claims.

The two price ladders

Fitbit's range is four devices, and all of them now sit under £150 on Amazon UK. Garmin's starts roughly where Fitbit's ends.

FitbitAmazon UKNearest Garmin we reviewAmazon UK
Inspire 3 (band, no GPS)£58.99No true equivalent; Forerunner 55 is the cheapest GPS Garmin we coveraround £114
Charge 6 (band, built-in GPS)£74.99Forerunner 55around £114
Versa 4 (square smartwatch)£98.99Forerunner 165 Music or vivoactive 6around £205 / £252
Sense 2 (Versa 4 plus ECG and stress sensor)£144.52Venu 4 (45mm)around £345

So the brand question is partly a budget question. If £100 is a hard ceiling, Garmin barely exists for you. Garmin does sell a vívosmart band nearer the Inspire 3's price, but we haven't reviewed it, so we've left it off the table rather than guess at how it compares.

Battery life and GPS

Garmin wins this comfortably, and the gap gets wider the more you exercise outdoors.

Claimed smartwatch batteryClaimed GPS recording
Fitbit Inspire 3up to 10 daysnone (uses your phone's GPS)
Fitbit Charge 6up to 7 daysbuilt in; Google doesn't list hours
Fitbit Versa 46+ daysbuilt in
Fitbit Sense 26+ daysup to 5 hours
Garmin Forerunner 55up to 2 weeksup to 20 hours
Garmin Forerunner 165 Musicup to 11 daysup to 19 hours
Garmin vivoactive 6up to 11 daysbuilt in
Garmin Venu 4 (45mm)up to 12 daysabout 19 hours

The Sense 2 figure is the one to look at. Google's Sense 2 spec page lists up to 5 hours of continuous GPS and warns that the always-on display, SpO2 and the cEDA stress sensor all mean more frequent charging. Five hours is a marathon for most people, but it isn't a long day in the Lakes, and you'll be charging the watch the day after. A Venu 4 would still have most of a week left.

On day-to-day battery, the Fitbits are closer than their reputation suggests. Owners of the Charge 6 tend to see three or four days with always-on display and regular GPS, which isn't far off what a Garmin manages with always-on switched on. Turn it off, though, and the Garmins pull clearly ahead.

Training metrics: Body Battery and Training Readiness vs Daily Readiness

Both brands now give you a morning number telling you whether to push or rest. They get there differently, and they charge differently for it.

Garmin has two layers. Body Battery is an energy score from 0 to 100 that drains with stress and activity and refills with sleep; it's on every Garmin in this comparison, down to the Forerunner 55 (our Body Battery guide explains how it's calculated). Training Readiness sits above it on the more advanced watches. Garmin's Venu 4 manual lists six inputs: last night's sleep score, recovery time, HRV Status, acute load, three nights of sleep history and three days of stress history. The Forerunner 165 Music gets HRV Status but not Training Readiness, which is one of the things you give up at £205.

Fitbit's answer is the Daily Readiness Score, built from heart rate variability, resting heart rate and recent sleep and activity. It's a sensible score; the catch is that it lives behind Google Health Premium. Without a subscription, a Fitbit still tracks sleep stages, heart rate and workouts, but it stops telling you what to do with them.

For anyone following a training plan, Garmin's system is deeper, because recovery time, training load and readiness feed into each other and into suggested workouts. For someone who walks, does a couple of gym sessions and wants a nudge on bad-sleep days, Fitbit's score is enough, provided you pay for it.

Subscriptions: Garmin Connect+ vs Google Health Premium

This is the difference most buyers don't spot until the trial runs out.

The Fitbit app is now the Google Health app, and Google's Google Health Premium page lists the subscription from £7.99 a month, with three months included. Premium adds the Gemini-based Google Health Coach alongside Daily Readiness, the detailed stress breakdown and most of the guided content. Steps, heart rate, sleep stages and GPS workouts stay free.

Garmin Connect is free. When Garmin launched Connect+ in March 2025, its press release said all existing features and data in Garmin Connect would remain free, and priced the new tier at $6.99 a month or $69.99 a year after a 30-day trial; check Garmin's UK app for local pricing. Connect+ adds AI-powered Active Intelligence insights, extra training guidance, badge challenges and expanded LiveTrack. Body Battery, HRV Status, sleep coaching and Training Readiness don't need it.

Run the numbers on a Charge 6. At £74.99 plus Premium at £7.99 a month from month four, the first year costs about £147 and the second year takes the total to roughly £243, which is more than a Forerunner 165 Music. Skip Premium and the Fitbit stays cheap, but you've lost its readiness score.

Smart features

Neither brand is a full smartwatch platform any more. Fitbit is the more phone-like of the two on the Versa 4 and Sense 2: Google Maps directions, Google Wallet, a speaker and mic for Bluetooth calls, and a large square screen. It lost third-party apps and Wi-Fi with this generation, and there's no music storage on any current Fitbit.

Garmin offers Garmin Pay, notifications and the Connect IQ store of watch faces and apps. Music storage is where it pulls ahead: the Forerunner 165 Music and the vivoactive 6 (8GB) both hold offline Spotify, Amazon Music or Deezer playlists, so you can run with headphones and leave the phone at home. The Venu 4 adds calls through your phone and an ECG app, matching the Sense 2 on that front. One quirk worth knowing if you use an iPhone: Garmin limits quick text replies to Android.

Model by model: which pairing makes sense

Inspire 3 (£58.99). There's nothing from Garmin we'd put against it. A 10-day battery, AMOLED screen, sleep staging and 24/7 heart rate on a band weighing under 18g is a lot for the money, and if you only want to move more and sleep better, it's the cheapest sensible entry to either brand. See our Fitbit Inspire 3 review.

Check the Fitbit Inspire 3 price on Amazon£58.99 at the time of writing

Charge 6 (£74.99) vs Forerunner 55 (around £114). The Charge 6 has built-in GPS, an ECG app and heart rate broadcasting to gym kit, all in a slim band; it's the best tracker under £100 for most people, as our Charge 6 review found. The Forerunner 55 costs about £40 more and is a proper running watch, with twice the battery, 20 hours of GPS and Body Battery for free. Runners should pick the Garmin. Everyone else, the Fitbit.

Check the Fitbit Charge 6 price on Amazon£74.99 at the time of writing

Versa 4 (£98.99) vs Forerunner 165 Music (around £205). At under £100 the Versa 4 has become a bargain square smartwatch with GPS, Google Maps and Wallet. The 165 Music costs about twice as much and gives you an AMOLED screen, a barometric altimeter, HRV Status, running power, onboard music and 19 hours of GPS. If you train for races, it's worth the difference; our Forerunner 165 Music review rates it the sensible running watch to buy.

Check the Garmin Forerunner 165 Music price on Amazonaround £205 at the time of writing

Sense 2 (£144.52) vs Venu 4 (around £345). The Sense 2 is the Versa 4 with an ECG app and a cEDA skin-conductance sensor for stress tracking, and at £144.52 it's well under its £219.99 list price. The Venu 4 costs more than twice as much, but it brings a metal case, 12 days of battery, around 19 hours of GPS, ECG and the full Training Readiness system. If health tracking is the point and £150 is the budget, the Sense 2 is fine. If you train seriously and don't race, our Venu 4 review explains why it's the Garmin to buy.

Check the Garmin Venu 4 price on Amazonaround £345 at the time of writing

Who should buy which

  • Budget under £100, mostly sleep and steps: Fitbit Inspire 3 or Charge 6. Garmin doesn't compete here in anything we've reviewed.
  • Runners and cyclists on any budget: Garmin. The Forerunner 55 at around £114 is the floor, and the 165 Music is the sweet spot.
  • People who refuse subscriptions: Garmin, because its recovery data is free; a Fitbit without Premium loses Daily Readiness.
  • Android users who want Google Maps and Wallet on a cheap watch: Fitbit Versa 4.
  • Hikers and anyone doing long days outdoors: Garmin, without much debate, since 5 hours of GPS on the Sense 2 won't cover a full mountain day.

If you've settled on Garmin and want help picking a model, our best Garmin watch guide ranks the range by use.

Our verdict

Garmin is the better brand for anyone who exercises with purpose. You get longer battery, GPS that lasts four times as long and a recovery system that doesn't disappear when a trial ends. Fitbit is the better brand for spending less: the Charge 6 at £74.99 does what most people need from a wearable, and nothing Garmin makes that we've reviewed gets close to it on price. Just budget £7.99 a month if you want the readiness score that makes it more than a step counter.

Recommended reads

Frequently asked questions

Is Garmin better than Fitbit?

For training, yes. Garmin watches last longer between charges, record GPS for far longer and give you HRV Status, Body Battery and (on the Venu 4 and Forerunner 265 upwards) Training Readiness without a subscription. Fitbit is better value under £150: the Charge 6 at about £75 and the Inspire 3 at about £59 undercut every Garmin we review, and they're easier to live with if you mostly care about steps, sleep and heart rate.

Do you have to pay a subscription for Garmin or Fitbit?

Neither forces one. Garmin Connect is free, and Garmin says all existing Connect features and data stay free; Garmin Connect+ is optional and adds AI insights, extra training guidance and expanded LiveTrack. Fitbit's app is now the Google Health app, and Google Health Premium starts at £7.99 a month with three months included on new devices. Premium is where Fitbit puts Daily Readiness and its Gemini-based coaching, so you lose more by not paying on Fitbit than on Garmin.

Which has better battery life, Garmin or Fitbit?

Garmin, at almost every price. Google rates the Inspire 3 at up to 10 days, the Charge 6 at up to 7 days and the Versa 4 and Sense 2 at 6+ days. Garmin quotes up to two weeks for the Forerunner 55, 11 days for the Forerunner 165 Music and vivoactive 6, and 12 days for the 45mm Venu 4. GPS is the bigger gap: Google lists the Sense 2 at up to 5 hours of continuous GPS, against roughly 19 to 20 hours on those Garmins.

What is the Garmin equivalent of a Fitbit Charge 6?

The nearest Garmin we review is the Forerunner 55 at around £114. It's a watch rather than a band, but it has built-in GPS, Body Battery, about two weeks of battery and 20 hours of GPS recording. The Charge 6 is slimmer, cheaper and adds an ECG app, so it's the better buy if you want a discreet tracker; the Forerunner 55 is better if you run.

Does Fitbit work with an iPhone, and does Garmin?

Both work with iPhone and Android. Fitbits set up through the Google Health app, and Garmin watches through Garmin Connect. On Garmin, quick text replies from the watch are Android only, so iPhone owners can read notifications but not answer them from the wrist.

Related guides

Best Exercise is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.co.uk. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no extra cost to you and never influences our independent reviews or rankings.