Elliptical vs Treadmill: Which Is Better for You?
Elliptical vs treadmill compared on joint impact, calories, fat burning, muscles worked, space and cost, with a clear recommendation for weight loss, running fitness and bad knees.
By Paul Kendrick, Cardio & Endurance Editor · Updated 23 September 2026
Heart rate zones turn "go easy" and "push hard" into numbers. Instead of guessing, you hold a heart rate range that matches what the session is for, whether that's an hour of easy base building or four minutes at the edge of your capacity. Every running watch and most cardio machines now show zones, but the default settings are often wrong for you, and wrong zones make the whole idea useless.
Here's how to set them properly and what to do with them.
Every zone is a percentage of your maximum heart rate, so this number matters more than anything else. There are three ways to get it, from least to most accurate.
Use a better formula. The familiar 220 minus age is off by a wide margin for many people. A large meta-analysis of 351 studies and over 18,000 people, followed by a lab validation in 514 adults, produced a more accurate equation: 208 minus 0.7 times age (Tanaka, Monahan and Seals, 2001). For a 50 year old that gives 173, against 170 from the old formula. The gap grows with age.
Do a field test. After a proper warm-up, run or row hard uphill for three minutes, recover for two, then go again flat out for two to three minutes. The highest number your chest strap records is close to your real max. Only do this if you're healthy and already training regularly.
Get tested. A lab or clinic ramp test gives a true max and often your lactate threshold too. It's the gold standard, and overkill for most people.
Formulas are averages, not you
Two 40 year olds can have max heart rates 20 beats apart. If a formula-based zone 2 feels like hard work, or zone 4 feels easy, trust the feeling and adjust. A field test fixes it for good.
Most watches and apps use a five-zone model based on percentage of max heart rate. The boundaries vary slightly between brands, but this is the common version:
| Zone | % of max HR | How it feels | What it trains |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 50 to 60% | Very easy, a brisk walk | Recovery, warm-ups |
| 2 | 60 to 70% | Easy, full sentences | Aerobic base, fat use, endurance |
| 3 | 70 to 80% | Moderate, short sentences | Aerobic fitness, tempo |
| 4 | 80 to 90% | Hard, a few words | Lactate threshold |
| 5 | 90 to 100% | Flat out, no talking | VO2 max, top-end speed |
For that 50 year old with a max of 173, zone 2 runs from 104 to 121 bpm and zone 4 from 138 to 156 bpm.
If you know your resting heart rate, the Karvonen method (percentage of heart rate reserve, meaning max minus resting) personalises zones further. Garmin, COROS and Amazfit all offer it in their settings as "HRR".
The best-supported pattern for endurance is simple: most sessions easy, a few genuinely hard, and not much in between. Coaches call it polarised or 80/20 training.
The evidence for it is real but smaller than the internet suggests. A 2024 meta-analysis of 17 studies found polarised training improved VO2 max a little more than other intensity splits, but only in programmes under 12 weeks and mainly in highly trained athletes; time trial performance came out the same either way (meta-analysis of polarised training). So the split isn't magic. Its big advantage for ordinary people is that it stops every session drifting into zone 3, which is hard enough to tire you out and too easy to push your top end.
A realistic week for someone doing four cardio sessions looks like this:
For general health rather than race fitness, the NHS asks for 150 minutes of moderate activity or 75 minutes of vigorous activity a week (NHS physical activity guidelines). Zone 2 and 3 count as moderate; zones 4 and 5 count as vigorous.
A chest strap is the single best upgrade for zone training; our heart rate monitor guide ranks the options, most of which pair with any watch or gym machine. For the watch itself, the Amazfit Balance 3 and Garmin Forerunner 265 both handle custom zones, heart rate reserve and strap pairing without fuss, and the Amazfit Cheetah 2 Ultra is the one for long trail days.
Estimate your maximum heart rate first. The formula 208 minus 0.7 times your age is more accurate than the old 220 minus age, especially over 40. Then set the zones as percentages of that number: roughly 50 to 60 percent for zone 1, 60 to 70 for zone 2, 70 to 80 for zone 3, 80 to 90 for zone 4 and 90 to 100 for zone 5. A field test or a lab test beats any formula.
Zone 2 is easy aerobic work, around 60 to 70 percent of max heart rate, where you can still hold a full conversation. It builds your aerobic base with little fatigue, which is why endurance plans put most of their weekly minutes there.
Most endurance plans put about 80 percent of sessions at easy intensity (zones 1 and 2) and about 20 percent hard (zones 4 and 5), with little in zone 3. For general fitness, the NHS target of 150 minutes of moderate or 75 minutes of vigorous activity a week covers it.
For steady running, cycling and rowing, mostly yes. For intervals, circuits and anything with a lot of arm movement, optical wrist sensors lag and misread, so a chest strap is the better tool if you're training by zones seriously.
That's cardiac drift. As you warm up and lose fluid, heart rate climbs even though pace stays the same. On long runs, either accept a slow drift of five to ten beats or slow down to hold the zone.
Elliptical vs treadmill compared on joint impact, calories, fat burning, muscles worked, space and cost, with a clear recommendation for weight loss, running fitness and bad knees.
Seven reformer Pilates exercises for beginners, with spring settings, step-by-step cues, the mistakes that make them harder than they should be, and a 30 minute home routine.
How to do a one arm cable lateral raise with the right pulley height, arm path and tempo. Muscles worked, why constant tension helps side delts, the mistakes that wreck it and the variations worth using.
How to do the incline bench press, the bench angle that actually hits your upper chest, muscles worked, common mistakes and the sets and reps that build the top of the pecs.
Best Exercise is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.co.uk. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no extra cost to you and never influences our independent reviews or rankings.