Chest Press vs Bench Press: Which Builds a Better Chest?
Chest press vs bench press compared: muscles worked, EMG and muscle growth evidence, why the weights never convert, and which to pick for your goal.
By Jacob Chambers, Founder & Lead Reviewer · Updated 11 November 2026
Cindy is a CrossFit benchmark workout: as many rounds as possible in 20 minutes of 5 pull-ups, 10 push-ups and 15 air squats. Your score is the number of rounds you finish, plus any reps into the next one, so a result is written as something like "14 + 8". It was first posted on CrossFit.com on 29 December 2004 and it's still one of the most repeated tests in the sport, mostly because it needs a bar, a patch of floor and nothing else (CrossFit's Cindy page).
On paper it looks gentle. Five pull-ups is not many, and nobody fears 15 squats. The trouble is that a round is 30 reps, and a respectable score means doing 400 to 600 of them without your push-ups falling apart at minute nine.
Set a clock for 20 minutes and work through this, in order, as many times as you can:
There's no prescribed rest and no weight. You finish all the reps of one movement before moving to the next, and you stop when the clock does. If the buzzer goes when you're four push-ups into round 13, your score is 12 rounds plus 9 reps (5 pull-ups and 4 push-ups).
CrossFit's page tells you to keep "a full range of motion" under fatigue but doesn't spell out judging standards for Cindy itself, so these are the standards most boxes hold you to:
Pull-up. Start from a dead hang with arms straight and finish with your chin clearly over the bar. Strict, kipping and butterfly pull-ups all count as Rx. If you're still building strict strength, our pull-ups guide covers the technique, and scapular pull-ups teach the shoulder position that makes every rep cleaner.
Push-up. Chest touches the floor at the bottom and elbows lock at the top, with your body moving as one plank. Sagging hips and half reps are the first things to appear when you tire, which is why this movement decides most scores. The full technique is in our push-ups guide.
Air squat. Hip crease drops below the top of the knee, then you stand until hips and knees are fully open. Heels stay down.
Count honestly. A score of 17 with shallow push-ups tells you nothing next time you test.
CrossFit publishes rough targets on its Cindy page, and they're the best reference available because they come from the people who wrote the workout. They're guidance for coaches and athletes, not competition standards.
| Level (per CrossFit.com) | Target score | Average round time |
|---|---|---|
| Beginner, scaled version | 8 to 10+ rounds | 2:00 to 2:30 |
| Intermediate, as prescribed | 8 to 10+ rounds | 2:00 to 2:30 |
| Rx | 20+ rounds | 1:00 or faster |
| Elite | 25+ rounds | 0:48 or faster |
The round times are simple division (20 minutes over the number of rounds), and CrossFit adds two pacing notes of its own: the fastest athletes finish a round in under 45 seconds, and getting every round under two minutes is a good goal for any level. Two minutes a round is exactly 10 rounds.
That leaves a wide gap between 10 and 20, and it's where most people who train regularly end up. Somewhere in the low to mid teens is a strong score for a recreational gym-goer with solid strict pull-ups, although that's our read of the gap in CrossFit's bands and not an official tier.
The volume is what catches people out, so here's the arithmetic:
| Rounds | Pull-ups | Push-ups | Squats | Total reps |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | 50 | 100 | 150 | 300 |
| 15 | 75 | 150 | 225 | 450 |
| 20 | 100 | 200 | 300 | 600 |
| 25 | 125 | 250 | 375 | 750 |
Twenty rounds is 100 pull-ups in 20 minutes. If your biggest single set is six, you won't get there on grit, and trying is how shoulders get hurt.
Cindy rewards the person who's boring. Pick a round time you can hold for all 20 minutes, then hold it.
Work backwards from your target. For 15 rounds you need a round every 80 seconds; for 12, every 100 seconds. Watch the clock at the end of each round for the first five minutes and you'll almost always find you're ahead of pace, because round one feels like nothing. That's the trap. Someone who opens with five 50-second rounds and then needs 2:30 per round by minute 12 finishes well behind someone who sat on 80 seconds from the start.
A few things that hold the pace together:
Save the push for the last two minutes. If you've paced it properly you'll have one faster round left, and that's worth more than a heroic first minute.
Scaling keeps the shape of the workout, which is 20 minutes of near-continuous movement, at a load you can sustain. CrossFit's rule of thumb is that you're ready for the prescribed version once you can do 5 to 7 or more pull-ups and 15 or more push-ups in a row. Below that, change the movement before you change anything else.
If you can't do pull-ups (or can only do a few). CrossFit prefers a vertical pull such as a leg-assisted pull-up and accepts a horizontal one such as the ring row.
If the push-ups break down. Put your hands on a bench or box for incline push-ups, or drop to your knees. Inclines are the better choice because your trunk still works as a plank and you can lower the surface as you get stronger.
If 20 minutes is too much. Halve it. A 10-minute half Cindy is a common scaled version, and CrossFit's own beginner variation is shorter and lighter still:
CrossFit's beginner version
As many rounds as possible in 12 minutes of 3 ring rows, 6 assisted push-ups and 9 squats. CrossFit suggests 8 to 10 or more rounds as the target. Intermediate athletes do the full workout and trim the pull-up or push-up reps per round if range of motion slips or the rests get long.
One more option sits between those: keep the 20 minutes and cut the reps to 3, 6 and 9. You still learn the pacing, with 40% less volume per round.
CrossFit's position is that Cindy doesn't need specialised training, and that extra pull-up and push-up volume tacked onto warm-ups is enough. It suggests 3 easy rounds of 5 strict pull-ups and 5 push-ups. The plan below builds on that idea with two short sessions a week on top of whatever else you do, then a retest. Use your scaled movements throughout if you scale the workout.
| Week | Session A | Session B |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Test: full Cindy (or your scaled version). Note the score and where the push-ups broke. | EMOM 10 minutes: 1 round of Cindy every 90 seconds at an easy pace (about 7 rounds) |
| 2 | 10-minute half Cindy at your target round time | 5 sets of pull-ups at about 60% of your max set, then 5 sets of push-ups the same way, 60 seconds rest |
| 3 | 2 x 8-minute Cindy with 4 minutes rest between, holding target pace | 12 minutes: 1 round every 75 to 90 seconds, push-ups always split 5 and 5 |
| 4 | Easy week: 3 rounds as a warm-up on two days, nothing to failure | Retest: full Cindy |
If strict pull-ups are the limiter, add negative pull-ups once a week, 3 to 5 reps with a slow five-second lower. Expect one to three extra rounds on the retest if you were new to pacing; less if you'd already done Cindy several times.
Want a different test once Cindy's familiar? Burpees make a brutal single-movement AMRAP, and our HYROX weights guide lays out the station loads if you're tempted by a race.
For most healthy people, yes, provided the volume matches what you've trained for. The NHS already recommends muscle-strengthening work on at least two days a week, and bodyweight pulling, pushing and squatting fit that well. There are two specific risks to respect.
The first is your shoulders. A systematic review of CrossFit-style training found that shoulders, knees and the back are the areas injured most often, although it rated 11 of its 12 included studies as poor quality (Prevalence of Injuries in CrossFit and HIFT). A separate review of risk factors found limited evidence that people newer to CrossFit get injured more, and its authors argued that novices need closer coaching (Risk Factors for Musculoskeletal Injury in CrossFit). Neither paper studied kipping on its own. Our advice is the conservative one that most coaches give: earn a few strict pull-ups before you kip, and don't do 75 or more swinging reps on shoulders that can't yet control one slow rep.
The second is sheer volume. Exertional rhabdomyolysis, where damaged muscle leaks its contents into the blood, is rare, but case reports exist of previously healthy people being hospitalised after a single exhaustive CrossFit session, including a 22-year-old who needed six days of treatment (case report). A case report shows it can happen, not how often. The practical lesson is simple, though: 300 squats and 200 push-ups is a lot for a first attempt, so start with the 10 or 12-minute version. Severe muscle pain and swelling with dark, cola-coloured urine in the days afterwards needs urgent medical attention.
A pull-up bar and roughly two square metres of floor. That's the whole list.
The bar matters more than you'd think, because the type decides which pull-ups you can do:
If you own the wall and want one bar that'll cope with every style, the GYM MASTER Heavy Duty is the wall-mounted pick from our round-up, at about £55 at the time of writing.
Check the GYM MASTER wall-mounted pull-up bar on AmazonNo bar and no rings? Inverted rows under a sturdy table will get you through a scaled Cindy, though a bar is the first thing to buy if you plan to repeat it. A mat or a folded towel under your hands helps on hard floors, and a phone timer propped where you can see it from the floor does the rest.
Cindy is a 20-minute AMRAP (as many rounds as possible) of 5 pull-ups, 10 push-ups and 15 air squats. You cycle through the three movements in that order until the clock hits 20:00, and your score is the number of full rounds plus any extra reps. CrossFit first posted it on 29 December 2004.
CrossFit's own guide lists 8 to 10 or more rounds as an intermediate score when done as prescribed, 20 or more rounds as a solid Rx score and 25 or more as elite. Twenty rounds means one full round every minute for 20 minutes, which adds up to 100 pull-ups, 200 push-ups and 300 squats.
Yes. Swap the pull-ups for ring rows, banded pull-ups or jumping pull-ups and keep everything else the same. CrossFit's beginner version is 12 minutes of 3 ring rows, 6 assisted push-ups and 9 squats, which is a sensible starting point if you're new to all three movements.
Each round is 30 reps, so 20 rounds is 600 reps: 100 pull-ups, 200 push-ups and 300 air squats. Ten rounds is half that, at 50 pull-ups, 100 push-ups and 150 squats.
You can, because the only kit Cindy needs is a pull-up bar and about two square metres of floor. Do strict pull-ups on a doorway bar instead of kipping, or use a wall-mounted bar or power tower if you want to kip. With no bar at all, ring rows or inverted rows under a sturdy table are the usual substitute.
Treat the full 20-minute version as a benchmark and retest it every four to eight weeks. Between tests, shorter pieces such as a 10-minute half Cindy or a few easy rounds in your warm-up build the pull-up and push-up capacity that moves your score.
Chest press vs bench press compared: muscles worked, EMG and muscle growth evidence, why the weights never convert, and which to pick for your goal.
How to do the cross body hammer curl (pinwheel curl): step-by-step form, muscles worked, how it differs from a standard hammer curl, mistakes, sets and reps.
Does reformer Pilates build muscle, and is it strength training? What the trials show, where spring resistance runs out, and how to pair it with weights.
PPLUL split explained: a full 5-day push, pull, legs, upper, lower programme with sets, reps and rest, plus a home-gym version and progression rules.
Best Exercise is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.co.uk. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no extra cost to you and never influences our independent reviews or rankings.